Stop Turbines In North Cornwall [STINC]

STINC - Home | About STINC | Davidstow | Titch Barrow | Otterham | Delabole | Existing Wind Farms | How To Object | Contacts | Downloads | Membership Form [PDF] | RAF Davidstow Moor | Links & Resources 

If you don't have a reader for PDF files, you can download it free here:  Get Adobe Reader


Questions to Community Windpower Ltd and their answers.

Tremail 29th November & Camelford 30th November 2007

Q) When are Community Windpower going to submit an application?

A) Hopefully before the end of the year, towards the end of December.

Q) Due to the extremely short notice given for the two exhibition days, about 7 days, where have you advertised locally to ensure that everone in the area, including those in neighbouring parishes, knows you will be here?

A) We put up some posters in shops in Camelford and on the notice board at Tremail. We sent an email to local radio and issued a short press release to local papers. We sent information pack to other parish councils in the area. We knocked on a few doors around Tremail on the day before the exhibition there. Of course it is also on our website.

Q) Many people in this area have no access to the internet and have no way of finding out what is happening other than local papers or radio. So, you placed not one advert in any newspaper to ensure it was published, you did no door-to-door leafletting in the wider Davidstow area or surrounding parishes? You did not contact any local radio station directly or personally to make sure the times of the exhibitions were aired? 

A) No.

Q) On your website it states: 'Following community consultation, Community Windpower have re-designed their Davidstow Community Windfarm proposal'. What community consultation was this?

A) From emails that we have received commenting on the proposal. 

Q) But that is not community consultation. That is feedback from your website! 

A) Well, it was also from the last exhibitions back in August.

Q) How big are the concrete bases for the turbines and how deep with the foundations be?

A) The concrete bases will be 15m x 15m (50ft x 50ft) and the depth will be 2m - 2.5 m (7ft - 8ft ) deep.

Q) Only 2m - 2.5m deep, even though the site is mostly peat bog and marsh?

A) Yes, this depth will be perfectly adequate!

Q) What percentage of birds do you expect to be killed by the turbines?

A) Very few if any, the birds will just fly around them.

Q) Even though the starlings are in flocks of about 1 million birds and turbulence from the turning blades tend to disorient birds and even suck them in?

A) They will just avoid them.

Q) On your literature it states: "Shadow Flicker - Shadow flicker can occur when the suns rays pass between turbine blades and through an aperture, like a window, and also when the sun is low in the sky (e.g. in the early morning or late evening).

We can accurately predict when this could happen and therefore design out the problem. The site will be designed to cause no disturbance to nearby residents."

Just how are you going to 'design out' shadow flicker?

A) We have designed it out by moving the turbines away from peoples' homes.

Q) But that is moving turbines, not designing out the problem based on predicted times of shadow flicker. What do you mean by "We can accurately predict when this could happen and therefore design out the problem" ?

A) As I said, we have designed it out by moving the turbines away from peoples' homes.

Q) Why are you proposing to build your turbines on such a sensitive area?

A) I think that this is a very good site for a wind farm.

Q) Have you actually been up there?

A) Yes of course, as the project manager I have been there many times and I think it is a very good site.

Q) Even though it will mean digging up peat bog and peat stores more CO2 per acre than a rainforest, you still think that it is a good site for a wind farm?

A) Yes

These are just some of the questions we put to them. We will post more when we have feedback from all of our members. If you have anything to contribute, please email it to webmaster@stinc.co.uk


Ponies grazing near Davidstow Airfield


Created by STINC

Last revised: December 09, 2007

Back to Top